During the birthday week (a bit ago) I chased my 24 oysters with 11 courses of exquisite edible art at Coi, courtesy of the ol’ bf (and Daniel Patterson). The restaurant certainly lived up to its credentials, though Paul and I did think that the food at Benu was better — but then again Benu will more than likely get some Michelin decorations of its own next year.

The atmosphere was warm if not a little new age-y with the stone arrangements everywhere (including in the bathroom sink). Silly. They try and source all of their ingredients from no more than 300 miles away. Local. We drank our Founder’s Art Reserve Cabernet because corkage was only $25. It was just the occasion we’d been waiting for.

Coi’s take on an aperitif — a frozen mandarin sour made with mandarin vodka gel, angostura bitters, kumquat, satsuma ice and Murray River salt. Crunchy, dry, refreshing (not juicy). If you’re wondering why anyone (or in particular, Chef DP/his sous chef) would choose river salt over sea salt it’s because the former is more floral and crunchier. Yes, I asked.


[frozen mandarin sour; mandarin vodka gel underneath]
Remember the ep where Tony Bourdain pulls a gooey duck out of the sand? It definitely tastes like it’s from the sea, that’s for sure. It’s also kind of crunchy, like cartilage. I thought the fennel worked really well here and the young kelp, which had been blanched, had a tender, pleasant mouthfeel that I was not expecting.

[manila clam and geoduck with bull kelp, meyer lemon and fennel]
Beets mixed with fresh cow and goat’s cheese topped with wild sprouts and flowers (that Paul identified to be miner’s lettuce, chickweed, wood sorel, baby thistle and radish green because he grew up naked in nature!). Not my favorite of the night though I was proud of P’s plant identification prowess. Looks like a (bloody) cow patty.

[beets roasted in hay, fresh cheese, wild sprouts and flowers]
A “crab melt” — crab on toast served cold with melted lardo over the top instead of cheese. It tasted very “Californian” indeed with the wheatgrass reduction and little pea shoots hopping all over the plate. But I think I would’ve preferred a regular crab melt… you know the kind that’s served warm.. maybe with melted lardo.

["californian" crab melt with lardo and wheatgrass]
I accidentally disturbed the puree before taking this photo. Serving an egg yolk hidden beneath the creamiest, most decadent cauliflower puree is an easy way to win people over. It was goooood.

[farm egg with cauliflower puree, caperberry, pickled shallot and nettle dandelion salsa verde]
“Earth and Sea” — this asiany soup has yuba (aka strips of tofu skin) in it instead of noodles. The textures and flavors were right up my alley.

[steamed tofu mousseline with a hint of ginger, mushroom dashi, yuba, radish, rice wine pickled turnip, fresh seaweed]
A foam made of sherry and mushroom stock conceals a stick-to-your-ribs chanterelle porridge – so delicious!

The porridge came with a bowl of crisp sunchokes, parsnip, salsify, burdock and parsley root.

[savory chanterelle porridge with crisp root vegetables, cress and sherry]
A very tender tenderloin from Prather Ranch that was served with a potato puree of the olive oil-y variety. Also on the plate were some “coastal grasses” tossed in champagne vinegar which balanced out the dish quite nicely.

[prather ranch beef, potato, coastal grasses, monterey cypress]
Coi’s play on a “cheese course” was a Tomme D’Ossau grilled cheese on Acme rye with onion marmalade two ways. Apparently Coi has always been big on the Tomme D’Ossau, which is a sheep’s milk cheese from the Pyrenees. Check out this photo I found on someone’s Flickr — did Coi srsly serve a piece of cheese just sitting on the plate like that? LOL I’m glad that wasn’t a course on our tasting menu — because I probably would’ve shit myself.

[grilled cheese, tomme d'ossau, rye, onion, pickled daikon]
The first of two desserts. This one had a crispy vanilla bean meringue and mint gelatin.

[lime sherbet, frozen yogurt, pomegranate, mint]
The “Bread and Chocolate” dessert was to die for, coming from someone who is not the biggest fan of dessert and who was incredibly stuffed by this point. The combination of the brioche, dark chocolate, pistachio and grenache was absolutely perfect. The dessert featured both a caramelized brioche and a brioche ice cream, and the dark chocolate pudding was surrounded by a ring of baked grenache. SO MUCH PLEASURE.

[brioche ice cream, pistachio, tarragon]
Some firethorn jellies to send us off!

Goooodnight.